Hello dear
Welcome to Gotham Bagels
At Gotham Bagels, we celebrate the art of bagel-making, bringing a piece of New York to Madison, Wisconsin. Nestled just off the state capitol square, we offer a casual yet vibrant atmosphere adorned with local memorabilia. Our extensive menu features 26 different bagel sandwiches, crafted using the freshest ingredients. With options for breakfast, brunch, or lunch, you're guaranteed a delicious experience whether you choose our smoky lox on an everything bagel or the classic pastrami. Enjoy outdoor seating and free Wi-Fi as you savor every bite. At Gotham, every bagel is an adventure, marrying tradition with a contemporary twist.
Today's Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
The G
24 Oz Loaf Cinnamon Babka
8 Oz. Container Of Cream Cheese
8 Oz. Container Of Specialty Cream Cheese
About
Gotham Bagels
Welcome to Gotham Bagels, a delightful gem nestled just a block away from Madison's state capitol square. This local deli specializes in authentic New York-style bagels, providing a true taste of the Big Apple right in Wisconsin. With a modern yet cozy ambiance, Gotham Bagels offers a vibrant atmosphere adorned with memorabilia from both New York and Madison.
At Gotham Bagels, the menu features an impressive selection of bagels and sandwiches, ensuring there's something for everyone. From the classic lox and cream cheese on an everything bagel to their standout offerings like The G Capocollo and Egg Cheddar sandwich, each dish is crafted with fresh ingredients and a genuine passion for food. Vegan options are also available, catering to diverse dietary preferences.
- Convenience: Gotham Bagels is easily accessible, offering delivery and takeout options. With outdoor seating and casual vibes, it’s a perfect spot for breakfast, brunch, or lunch.
- Catering: Planning an event? Their catering options, like the Riverside Park Platter, are ideal for group gatherings, showcasing a variety of delicious spreads, lox, and more.
- Extras: Don't forget to try their kettle chips or potato latkes for a satisfying side dish that complements your meal.
The local reviews echo a combination of enthusiasm and constructive feedback. Customers praise Gotham Bagels for its authentic New York experience, with one patron describing the delightful scene of enjoying a bagel while gazing at the Bartell Theater. Others have noted the occasional long wait times, but the overall sentiment remains positive, emphasizing the quality of food and the welcoming service.
As you indulge in the fresh bagels, you can enjoy complimentary perks like free Wi-Fi and gender-neutral restrooms. Whether you’re dining solo, with family, or in a group, Gotham Bagels creates an inviting environment that feels like home away from home.
In my experience, the moment I stepped into Gotham Bagels, the aroma of freshly baked bagels captivated my senses. I could hardly wait to sample their famed sandwiches, and let me tell you, they did not disappoint. With a diverse menu, friendly staff, and an ambiance that resonates with warmth and character, Gotham Bagels is set to become your favorite breakfast or brunch spot.
So next time you’re in Madison, make sure to pay a visit to Gotham Bagels. Your taste buds will thank you.
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ Located just one block off from the state capitol square, I was able to find lots of street parking, at 10am on a Tuesday, right in front of the store. Walking in, the store is nicely decorated with both NY and Madison memorabilia. It is very sunny with big plate glass windows looking onto Mifflin Street and the Bartell Theatre. There are two eating counters, one facing south the other facing Mifflin. Also a couple long community tables. There is a choice of 26 different bagels sandwiches, multiple types of bagels as well as cream cheeses. I chose #3, lox and cream cheese on an "everything" bagel, toasted. The wait from order to delivery was seven minutes. The sandwich was delicious, with chewy bagel, a generous serving of lox, the right amount of cream cheese and capers ($1 extra). A nice shop for authentic bagels. ”
“ For the first time, I found myself near Gotham Bagels when I was hungry. I'd seen it many times, but just never had the time to get there, or I'd already eaten elsewhere. I opted for a #17--The Williamsburg. Hot pastrami, strong mustard, on an everything bagel. It came with a spicy dill pickle spear and a four-ounce cup of coleslaw. First, the good: The bagel was tasty, the pastrami was really good, and being able to eat a bagel while staring out a huge window at the Bartell Theater while I was crammed into the place shoulder-to-shoulder with strangers made me feel like I was in New York. Second, the mediocre: The bagel was overly tough. It didn't make a good sandwich. I imagine if I was just eating the bagel with some schmear, it would have been okay, but as a sandwich, it was subpar. The sign also claimed the bagel was "piled high" with pastrami, and in New York this means something. However, it was just a normal amount of pastrami. Pretty lacking, actually. Could have used another couple of ounces of meat to make it "piled high." Third, the bad: There really wasn't anything I found overly lacking. There are a few things I'd complain about if it mattered, though. The location stinks. It's inconvenient to get to. Street parking is always full and it's at least a three-block walk to the nearest parking ramp (which charges a flat fee on the weekends). The girl at the counter was timid and too quiet for such a crowded place. The layout of the store was a little inconvenient. It took more than 15 minutes to get two bagel sandwiches, which I think any NY bagel place would have found appalling. But none of this was really "bad." Just not great. I would definitely go back for another sandwich at some point, but I'm not in a rush to get back there. ”
“ Love love love this place! Right off the square and just like NYC bagels! Great service great vibe with lots of old time pictures & the freshest bagels you can imagine! ”
“ Bagels were solid but the special sandwiches is where it's at! When I said I wanted my bagel NY style they delivered. Everyone we interacted with was super friendly and we will definitely be back! ”
“ Opens at 8am on weekdays :) I showed up early and still wasn't the first in line! The Calabrian chili bagel was delicious. Love this little place with so much character! ”
“ Stopped in on a weekend around lunch time and got some breakfast bagel sandos. They have a neon sign out front that says espresso but we were told they do not... just regular pour it yourself hot coffee. Great bagels, long wait time as they ran out of everything bagels (they didn't mention it when we ordered though), but they did make more fresh! Very good! Would definitely come back for breakfast! ”
