Gotham Bagels Menu

Welcome to Gotham Bagels, your premier destination for authentic New York-style bagels right here in Madison, WI. Nestled just off the state capitol square, Gotham Bagels brings a vibrant blend of NYC charm and Midwestern warmth. Their menu features an impressive lineup of 26 signature sandwiches, crafted with fresh ingredients and served on your choice of delectable bagels, including classic options like everything and sesame.

Highlights include the Jewish Girl, a delightful combination of egg whites, hot smoked salmon, and avocado mash, making your morning brighter. Their catering options offer beautifully arranged platters, perfect for any occasion, including the Riverside Park Platter, overflowing with lox and spreads.

With a welcoming atmosphere featuring memorabilia and a community spirit, Gotham Bagels promises not just great food but an experience that transports you straight to the heart of New York. Whether you're grabbing a quick bite or enjoying a leisurely brunch, you're in for a treat!